Manganese Steel vs. Ceramic Composite Jaw Plates: Which is Best for Your Crusher?

Release Time: 2025-12-17

Introduction: The "Crushing" Reality of Crusher Jaw Plate Casting

In the aggregate and mining industries, the jaw crusher is the frontline warrior. It takes the harshest punishment, reducing massive boulders into manageable stones. But this frontline role comes at a steep price: wear.

For quarry operators, the jaw plate (or jaw die) is not just a spare part; it is a consumable that dictates the rhythm of the entire plant. When a jaw plate wears out prematurely, the costs ripple through the operation. It's not just the purchase price of a new set of plates. It’s the crane rental, the maintenance crew's wages, the halted production line, and the lost tonnage that can never be recovered.

For decades, the industry standard has been High Manganese Steel. It is reliable, tough, and predictable. But as ore grades become harder and abrasive content (like silica) rises, the limitations of traditional steel are becoming apparent. Enter the challenger: Ceramic Composite Technology.

This guide dives deep into the metallurgy and economics of these two materials. We will explore why High Manganese Steel has reigned supreme for so long, why Ceramic Composites are disrupting the market, and how Haitian Heavy Industry’s specific casting capabilities can help you achieve a service life that is 2 to 3 times longer than standard OEM parts.

The Incumbent: High Manganese Steel (The Industry Standard)

To understand the future, we must appreciate the past. High Manganese Steel (often called Hadfield Steel) has been the gold standard for crusher wear parts since its invention in 1882. Even today, it comprises the vast majority of jaw plates sold globally, including the standard OEM parts for brands like Metso, Sandvik, and Terex.

1. The "Magic" of Work Hardening

The unique property of high manganese steel is its ability to work harden. In its "as-cast" state, manganese steel is relatively soft (around 200–220 Brinell Hardness). This softness allows it to be tough and ductile, meaning it won’t crack under the massive shock loads of a jaw crusher.

However, when the rock impacts and compresses against the jaw plate surface, the metallurgical structure of the steel changes. The surface layer transforms from soft austenite to hard martensite, reaching hardness levels of 500–600 Brinell. Essentially, the harder you hit it, the harder it gets.

Meanwhile, the core of the plate remains ductile, preventing catastrophic failure or cracking.

2. The Grades: Mn13 vs. Mn18 vs. Mn22

Not all manganese steel is created equal. At Haitian Heavy Industry, we cast various grades to suit different crushing environments:

Mn13Cr2 (Standard): The baseline material. Excellent for soft to medium rock (limestone). It requires significant impact to work harden. If used on abrasive but low-impact material, it will wear out quickly because it never achieves its full hardness potential.
Mn18Cr2 (Premium): The modern standard. The higher manganese content (18%) allows it to work harden faster and deeper. It offers a better balance of wear resistance and toughness. For most general quarry applications, this is the "safe" choice.
Mn22Cr2 (Super High): Designed for extreme impact environments. The extra manganese provides extreme toughness, allowing the plate to withstand massive boulders without cracking, while the chromium assists in fighting abrasion.

3. The Limitation of Manganese

Manganese steel has an Achilles' heel: It needs impact.

In applications where the rock is extremely abrasive (high silica content) but friable (crumbles easily), the jaw plate may not receive enough impact force to trigger the work-hardening effect. In this scenario, the steel remains soft and is essentially "machined away" by the sliding abrasion of the rock. This is where operators see jaw plates washing out in weeks rather than months.

The Challenger: Ceramic Composite Technology

If manganese steel is the "hammer," ceramic composite technology is the "diamond cutter." This technology represents a paradigm shift in wear part manufacturing, moving from a single material solution to a Metal Matrix Composite (MMC).

1. What is a Ceramic Composite Jaw Plate?

A ceramic composite jaw plate is a hybrid. It uses a metal matrix (usually high manganese steel or high chrome steel) as the body of the plate to provide structural integrity and shock absorption. However, embedded within the wear face—specifically in the high-wear zones—are extremely hard ceramic columns or particles (typically Zirconia Toughened Alumina or ZTA).

2. The Synergy of Hardness and Toughness

Ceramics are incredibly hard (approaching the hardness of diamonds), making them virtually impervious to abrasive wear. However, ceramics are also brittle; if you made a whole jaw plate out of ceramic, it would shatter instantly upon the first crush.

By embedding ceramic inserts into a steel matrix, manufacturers like Haitian Heavy Industry achieve the best of both worlds:

The Steel Matrix absorbs the crushing force and impact, ensuring the plate doesn't crack.
The Ceramic Inserts take the brunt of the abrasive wear, resisting the gouging action of silica and granite.

3. Haitian's "Honeycomb" Embedment Technology

Casting these plates is an art form. Simply throwing ceramic beads into molten steel will result in them floating to the top or clumping, creating weak spots.

Haitian Heavy Industry utilizes a proprietary honeycomb ceramic preform technology.

Precise Placement: Engineers identify the "high wear zone" of the jaw plate (usually the lower third where the crushing ratio is highest).
Infiltration: During casting, the molten manganese steel infiltrates the porous ceramic preforms. As the metal solidifies, it mechanically locks the ceramic particles in place.
Result: A wear face that is 50-70% ceramic by volume in the critical zones, supported by a ductile steel backbone.

Head-to-Head Comparison: Which is Best for You?

To help you decide, we have compared these materials across four critical categories: Wear Life, Cost Efficiency, Reliability, and Application Suitability.

1. Wear Life

Manganese Steel: Service life is the baseline. In highly abrasive granite (250+ MPa compressive strength), a standard Mn18 jaw plate might last 300–400 hours.
Ceramic Composite: In the same granite application, Haitian's ceramic composite plates consistently deliver 2 to 3 times the service life (900–1200 hours). The ceramics resist the micro-cutting action of the rock, preserving the tooth profile of the jaw plate for much longer.

2. Cost Efficiency (Cost-Per-Ton)

Manganese Steel: Low initial purchase price. However, frequent changes mean higher labor costs and more downtime.
Ceramic Composite: The initial purchase price is higher (often 1.5x to 2x the cost of manganese) due to the expensive ceramic materials and complex casting process.

The Math: If a ceramic plate costs 2x but lasts 3x longer, you save 33% on direct part costs alone.
The Bonus: You also eliminate two change-outs, saving crane fees, labor, and gaining days of production revenue.

3. Application Suitability

Best for Manganese (Mn18/Mn22):

Variable Feed: Recycling concrete with rebar (steel can damage ceramics), or applications with uncrushable tramp iron.
Massive Impact: Primary crushers handling 1-meter+ boulders where shock loads are extreme.

Best for Ceramic Composites:

Hard Rock: Granite, Basalt, Quartzite, Gold Ore, Copper Ore.
High Abrasion: Rock with high Silica (SiO2) content.
Fixed Operations: Quarries with consistent feed material where "uncrushables" are filtered out.

The Manufacturing Edge: Why Foundry Quality Matters

Whether you choose Manganese or Ceramic, the performance of the plate is dictated by the quality of the casting process. A "recipe" for Mn18 is useless if the foundry cannot execute it perfectly.

Haitian Heavy Industry's manufacturing infrastructure ensures that the theoretical benefits of these materials are realized in the pit.

1. Heat Treatment: The Soul of the Casting

The difference between a jaw plate that lasts and one that cracks is often heat treatment.

The Haitian Standard: We utilize Automated Natural Gas Heat Treatment Furnaces with PID intelligent temperature control. This ensures the temperature within the furnace is uniform within ±5°C.
Water Quenching: For manganese steel, precise water quenching is critical to retain the austenitic structure. Our automated systems ensure the transfer from furnace to water tank happens in seconds, locking in the toughness.

2. Precision Molding

We employ DISA Vertical Molding lines and Lost Foam Casting processes.

Dimensional Accuracy: Traditional sand casting often results in rough surfaces and poor fitment. Haitian's lost foam process ensures the back of the jaw plate is perfectly flat. A flat back ensures 100% contact with the crusher frame, preventing the plate from "rocking" and cracking under load.
No Defects: Our vacuum-assisted casting removes gas pockets, ensuring the internal structure of the steel is dense and free of porosity.

3. Quality Control

Before any plate leaves our facility, it undergoes rigorous testing:

Spectral Analysis: Verifies the chemical composition (e.g., ensuring Mn content is truly 18% and Cr is 2%).
Impact Testing: Confirms the toughness of the batch.
Ultrasonic Testing: Specifically for ceramic composites, we check the bond between the ceramic and steel to ensure no delamination will occur.

Real-World Case Study: The Granite Challenge

Location: Anhui Province, Granite QuarryEquipment: Metso C125 Jaw Crusher

The Problem: The client was crushing high-silica granite. Standard OEM Mn18 jaw plates were washing out every 15 days. The tooth profile would wear smooth after just 10 days, reducing crushing efficiency and causing slippage (rocks popping out of the chamber).

The Solution: Haitian Heavy Industry engineered a custom set of Ceramic Composite Jaw Plates. We embedded ZTA ceramic columns into the lower 40% of the fixed and swing jaws—the zone of highest wear.

The Results:

Service Life: The new plates lasted 48 days (3.2x life increase).
Production Efficiency: Because the ceramics resisted wear, the tooth profile remained sharp for 40 days, maintaining high throughput and consistent product shape.
Savings: despite the plates costing double the price of standard manganese, the client reduced their annual wear part budget by 35% and eliminated 16 maintenance shutdowns per year.

Conclusion: Making the Right Choice

So, which is best?

Choose High Manganese Steel (Mn18/Mn22) if you are dealing with recycling, very large feed sizes with extreme impact, or if you are on a strict immediate budget constraint. It is the "safe," versatile choice.
Choose Ceramic Composite if you are crushing hard, abrasive, virgin rock and your goal is to minimize downtime. If you are tired of changing plates every few weeks, this technology is the solution.

At Haitian Heavy Industry, we don't just sell castings; we sell uptime. With an annual capacity of 30,000 tons and a library of molds for all major brands (Metso, Sandvik, Terex, Trio), we can supply the exact solution your plant needs.

Ready to stop changing parts and start crushing more rock?

Contact our engineering team today for a free wear analysis. We will review your rock type and current wear patterns to recommend the perfect alloy for your operation.

The Impact of Material Composition on the Service Life of Wear Parts in Concrete Batching Plants

Large Crusher Jaw Plate Factory Price List: How to Get Accurate Quotes, MOQ & Best Value